• About
  • Herbal
    • Angelica
    • Calendula
    • Carrier Oils
    • Chamomile
    • Dandelion
    • Elderberry
    • Ginger
    • Greener Cleaning
    • Herbal Infusions and Preparations
    • Herbs for Yule
    • Infusing oils…
    • Lavender
    • Lemon Balm
    • Lemongrass
    • Luffa
    • Peppermint
    • Poppy
    • Rose
    • Sage
    • The Herbal Code
    • This Kitchen Witch’s Library
    • Valerian
    • Yarrow
    • The First Thing You Need (an article)
  • Magic & Ritual
    • Chakras 101
    • Defining Magic
    • Defining Witchcraft
    • Sacred Time (article)
    • Spellwork (article)
  • Paganism
    • A Book List for Contemporary Paganism
    • Defining Paganism
    • Hellenismos (article)
    • Nature Religion for Real, an article by Chas S. Clifton
    • Pagan Apologetics (article)
    • Pagan views of deity
    • Paganism’s Traditions and Paths
    • The Delphic Maxims
    • The Druid Path(s)
    • Walking With Your God
    • Wheel of the Year
      • Tales for the Longest Night
  • Parenting
    • A Book List for Pagan Families
    • A Children’s Herbal
      • Bee Careful (tips for parents and kids)
    • A Pagan Student in Your School
    • Baby Sling Types
    • Crafts & Projects for Kids
      • Alphabet Book
      • Mermaid Wrap Skirt
      • Sleepy Spell Bear
      • Underwater View-finder
      • Yarn Dolls
    • Mealtime Prayers for Pagan Families
    • Nature Prayers for Families
    • Nightey-Night: Bedtime Prayers for Pagan Babies
    • Our Afterschooling
      • Copywork & Recitation
        • PreK-1st Copywork and Recitiation
    • Pagan Pregnancy Correspondences
    • Raising Pagan Children (article)
    • Reading Myths with Kids
    • Ritual ideas for small children
    • The Sabbat Faeries
  • About me

bay witch musings

~ thoughts on parenting, paganism, science, books, witchcraft, nature, feminism, unitarian universalism, herbalism, cooking, conservation, crafting, the state of humanity, and life by the sea

bay witch musings

Tag Archives: science

WWDY: March for Science Edition

24 Monday Apr 2017

Posted by thalassa in education, enviornment, family, nature, pagan parenting, paganism, parenting, politics, protest, science

≈ 2 Comments

Tags

#marchforscience, #scienceactivism, activism, conservation, feminism, nature, protest, science, women in science

What We Did Yesterday:

IMAG1931IMAG1954 (2)IMAG1966 (2)IMAG1937IMAG1932IMAG1934 (2)IMAG1935IMAG1942IMAG1936IMAG1973IMAG1953

Share me with your friends!

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...

reMEDIAted: bad journalism meets scientific illiteracy

21 Sunday Aug 2011

Posted by thalassa in science

≈ 3 Comments

Tags

alien invasion, health, journalism, media, responsibility, science

When I happened upon the article a few days ago, it was first the title that bothered me.  Please, go read it…I’ll wait! (if you have time, I also recommend reading the actual paper for comparison)

My problem was mainly that the title seemed very disproportionate to the overall topic of the article (though I realize this is a convention of  journalistic writing), but also because…well, the article just seemed…off, for lack of a better term.

And so, I felt compelled to vet a story by a major news outlet.  Which, of course, was then picked up by other news outlets (Faux News strikes again!).  10 minutes on Google, and I can tell you that this is not only a ridiculously misrepresented piece of fluff, but like most misrepresented news stories, dangerously so.

So…here’s the part of the story that The Guardian–and every other news outlet left out (and probably won’t bother to report).

This is not some government report written by government scientists on the possibilities of alien visitation and what responses should be taken.

From the blog of one of authors:

A while ago, a couple good friends of mine (Seth Baum and Jacob Haqq-Misra) approached me about a paper they were writing, and asked if I wanted to join them on it. The paper was a review of all the different proposed situations for contact with an alien civilization. I didn’t think this was particularly important. After all, I consider the likelihood of contact with an alien civilization to be low. It certainly wasn’t urgent, as I don’t expect this to happen anytime soon. But… it sounded like fun and I decided to join in on it. So we wrote the paper, but I have to admit that Seth and Jacob put in the vast majority of the work on it. One of the scenarios we considered in the review was the possibility that an alien civilization would contact us because they were concerned about the exponential growth of our civilization, as evidenced by climate change. This isn’t an entirely new idea; remember, this was a review effort. Indeed, Keanu Reaves recently played a similar alien in the movie “The Day the Earth Stood Still.” There were lots of other ideas we reviewed, but this was probably the most provocative.

Its actually a scientific paper written by three  guys who had gone to grad school together for a scientific journal, whose goal is to publish:

original contributions in all fields of basic, engineering, life and social space sciences and of space technology related to: the peaceful scientific exploration of space, its exploitation for human welfare and progress and the conception, design, development and operation of space-borne and Earth-based systems. (source)

Somehow, this hypothetical exercise by a couple of college buddies got picked up by a major news outlet and turned into a major news story (pending deadline? slow news day?)…a news story written in such a way that the average reader assumes this is NASA report, and a news story (particularly by the outlets that picked it up later) that paints scientists (and therefor science) as *out there* and even becomes partisan fodder for all that is wrong with the federal government (all because the convention of scientific journal authorship calls for one’s academic affiliation, and one of the authors happened to work for NASA).

So here’s the deal, folks. Yes, I work at NASA. It’s also true that I work at NASA Headquarters. But I am not a civil servant… just a lowly postdoc. More importantly, this paper has nothing to do with my work there. (source)

“When data are distorted, there are real world consequences.”

Many researchers have seen their results distorted beyond recognition as they filtered through mass media. A decade ago, three medical researchers (Ian J. Deary, Martha C. Whiteman, and F.G.R. Fowkes) published a study about the link between personality and heart disease, finding that “men and women with more submissiveness were less likely to have a myocardial infarction.”

The first few stories, in major newspapers, were fairly accurate. But the researchers watched in horror as their results were recast as an anti-feminist message, with headlines such as, “Do what hubby says and you’ll live longer; Professors’ shock advice to women,” and “Put down that rolling pin, darling, it’s bad for your heart.”

The British medical journal The Lancet reported on the media’s distortion of this research, quoting one newspaper editor who lauded the “rolling pin” phrase: “How many readers, I wonder, were able to pass that headline without the flicker of a smile?” he said. “For this is what the game is about: stopping readers in their tracks long enough to read the story.” (source)

Unfortunately this seems to be the media’s modus operandi for many stories–flashy headline, selective reporting of “facts” and misrepresentation of conclusions.  Combine shoddy journalism with the low rate of scientific literacy in this country, and its no surprise that so many people have taken this news story at face value, not even realizing that something was “off” about it.  Hopefully the author that is doing post-doc research at NASA won’t be in too much trouble for all of this…but what about when its someone’s health on the line, or when someone’s life decisions are influenced by a false or misleading report or when public policy (or lack of public policy) that influences our health and welfare is decided ?

(Linda) Schwartz and colleague Steven Woloshin analyzed U.S. newspaper, TV and radio reports on research from five major scientific meetings. Their findings:

  • Only 2 of 175 stories about unpublished studies noted that the study was unpublished.
  • One-third of the articles failed to mention how many participants were in a study [studies with only a few test subjects are sometimes later refuted by larger studies].
  • 40 percent of the reports did not quantify the main result of the research.
  • Just one out of 17 news reports on animal studies noted that results might not apply to humans.

“Unless journalists are careful to provide basic study facts and highlight limitations, the public may be misled about the meaning, importance and validity of the research,” Woloshin said. (source)

Don’t get me wrong, its not all mean ole journalists kicking poor little science like a beat up soccer ball, just trying to score with the big story.  If you read the article from The Guardian, you may have checked out the comments.  How many readers took that story at face value?  How many blew it out of proportion as an opportunity to knock NASA (whom they wrongly thought was responsible for the story), to complain about science and scientists, and even to use it as a way to promote a political ideology?  It took me all of 10 minutes on Google to find and read through the blogs and personal websites of the three authors for the pertinent information.  We too are responsible when we stop in our tracks and read an article because of the flashy headline without questioning it, and without demanding better journalism from our news sources when it is seen to be false.

For the rest of us media consumers, we have to remember that new, surprising, or scary reports are designed to attract (and often get) our increasingly fragmented attention. We have to weigh these reports, and put them into context, through a combination of scientific and media literacy: Who conducted the study, why, and with what funding? How many people were studied, for how long, and who and where were they? If the research posits dangers in your coffee or toothpaste, how big are these risks compared to other health risks, or compared to potential benefits of that habit or product? (source)

The moral of this story?  Don’t get your science from the media, and don’t let the media frame your ideology.

36.768209 -76.287493

Share me with your friends!

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...
None is as free as one born on the wave, Born on the wave to the song of the sea; None can be brave until they are free, Free of all, but the call of the sea.

Month By Month

topics

About me

*Just an FYI: If you are wondering why there's not been a new post recently, new posts have been a bit slowed down by the new job...*

I am a (occasionally doting) wife, a damn proud momma of two adorable and brilliant children, a veteran of the United States Navy, beach addict, (American) Civil War reenactor and Victorian natural history aficionado, lover of steampunk, canoeing fanatic, science professional (and amateur in my preferred field), graduate student, and semi-erratic blogger.

If you have found this blog, you have also figured out that we are a Pagan family.  More aptly, I would describe my theological belief as a pragmatic sort of pantheism with a polytheistic practice and my religion as Unitarian Universalist Pagan.  I practice a bioregional witchery and herbalism (foraging ftw!), mainly working with domestic and elemental magics, and I have a thing for sea deities. For the most part, my blog covers a bit of all of these things, with a bit of randomness tossed in from time to time.

I enjoy playing with my kids, chillin with the hubster, swimming, being nerdy, the great outdoors, NCIS re-runs, chai tea--iced or hot, yoga, trashy romance novels, singing off key, kitchen experiments (of the culinary and non types), surfing the internet and painting.  I also like long walks on the beach and NPR's Science Friday and Neil deGrasse Tyson.  I love to read, sleep in on the weekend, and make the Halloween costumes for my kids every year. I am passionate about watershed ecology and local conservation efforts and vehemently anti-disposable plastics. But most of all...I'm just trying to take extravagant pleasure in the act of being alive.

Follow Musings on Facebook!

Follow Musings on Facebook!

Tweeting Randomness

  • As a family, we are Pagan. That means, of course, that I have spent more time teaching my children about Christiani… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 4 days ago
  • Goals. https://t.co/bAVpHykQQm 5 days ago
  • Wtf. There is no age too young to learn about the evils of genocide. After all, the people that perpetuate it dont… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 5 days ago
  • Omg, so yummy...chicken-basil-pineapple salad with a white basalmic-honey-Sriracha dressing. Its spicy, tart, refr… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 5 days ago
  • Wednesday summer snack! Fresh blackberry, a drizzle of forest honey, and burbon vanilla gelato... https://t.co/W2OMIbNpG9 6 days ago

RSS Feed

Goodreads

Pagan Devotionals--seeking inspiration everywhere
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

Blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • bay witch musings
    • Join 1,624 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • bay witch musings
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: